Sylvan Beach, New York

Vacation Rentals in Sylvan Beach, New York

Discover 34 vacation rental properties in Sylvan Beach. From 1 to 8 bedrooms. Average $337/night. 100% have pools.

34 verified listings Book securely on VRBO Prices updated March 2026

34 properties available

The Canal View Cottage

The Canal View Cottage

2 beds 1 bath
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$199/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
Sylvan Beach Cottage

Sylvan Beach Cottage

3 beds 1 bath
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$377/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
Single Family Beach Home steps away from the beautiful Sylvan Beach

Single Family Beach Home steps away from the beautiful Sylvan Beach

4 beds 1 bath
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$343/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
!!!Beautiful Sylvan Beach Sunsets!!!

!!!Beautiful Sylvan Beach Sunsets!!!

4 beds 1 bath
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$362/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
"The Fabulous Beach House"

"The Fabulous Beach House"

3 beds 2 baths
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$281/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
SAND BETWEEN YOUR TOES AND SUNSETS OUT YOUR BACK DOOR!

SAND BETWEEN YOUR TOES AND SUNSETS OUT YOUR BACK DOOR!

2 beds 1 bath
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$225/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
Lake front condo in the heart of Sylvan Beach

Lake front condo in the heart of Sylvan Beach

3 beds 2 baths
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$376/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
The Bella Vista Beachfront Cottage ....Perfect For Families

The Bella Vista Beachfront Cottage ....Perfect For Families

4 beds 1 bath
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$471/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
MOST POPULAR SPOT ON SYLVAN BEACH! NEXT DOOR TO LAKE HOUSE CASINO

MOST POPULAR SPOT ON SYLVAN BEACH! NEXT DOOR TO LAKE HOUSE CASINO

2 beds 1 bath
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$260/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
Beachfront, 5 Bedroom Home w/ Tennis/pickle-ball Court

Beachfront, 5 Bedroom Home w/ Tennis/pickle-ball Court

5 beds 1 bath
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$263/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
New Beach House at Sunset Cottages

New Beach House at Sunset Cottages

3 beds 1 bath
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$653/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
BEST LOCATION IN SYLVAN BEACH!! "WHITE CAPS" BEACH HOUSE

BEST LOCATION IN SYLVAN BEACH!! "WHITE CAPS" BEACH HOUSE

8 beds 3 baths
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$804/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
Main Street Retreat

Main Street Retreat

2 beds 1 bath
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$151/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
Village apartment in the middle of the action

Village apartment in the middle of the action

2 beds 1 bath
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$201/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
The House near Sylvan Beach

The House near Sylvan Beach

4 beds 1 bath
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$218/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
It's All About Location!

It's All About Location!

2 beds 1 bath
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$215/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
One of a kind....THE BEACHSIDE VILLA WITH PRIVATE BEACH

One of a kind....THE BEACHSIDE VILLA WITH PRIVATE BEACH

4 beds 4 baths
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$509/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
Serenity Beach House..Perfect For Families!

Serenity Beach House..Perfect For Families!

4 beds 2 baths
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$476/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
Location, location!! Just a few steps away from the Sandy beach!

Location, location!! Just a few steps away from the Sandy beach!

2 beds 1 bath
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$237/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
Waterfront Lake House, Close to Casino, 1st Floor

Waterfront Lake House, Close to Casino, 1st Floor

2 beds 1 bath
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$246/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
Booking now for 2024! Close to "everything Sylvan"!

Booking now for 2024! Close to "everything Sylvan"!

5 beds 2 baths
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$182/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
Sylvan Beach Cottage on Sylvan Beach

Sylvan Beach Cottage on Sylvan Beach

3 beds 1 bath
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$306/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
It's All About Location!

It's All About Location!

2 beds 1 bath
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$199/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
Best Beach House “Sweet Spot” on Sylvan Beach

Best Beach House “Sweet Spot” on Sylvan Beach

3 beds 2 baths
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$676/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
Brand New 5 Bedroom Lux Sylvan Beach House W Private Beach & Free WIFI

Brand New 5 Bedroom Lux Sylvan Beach House W Private Beach & Free WIFI

5 beds 2 baths
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$799/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
Waterfront Lake House, 2nd Floor, Boat Dock

Waterfront Lake House, 2nd Floor, Boat Dock

2 beds 1 bath
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$243/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
Cozy Canal Front Home in Wonderful Sylvan Beach, NY

Cozy Canal Front Home in Wonderful Sylvan Beach, NY

3 beds 1 bath
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$262/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
It's All About Location!

It's All About Location!

2 beds 1 bath
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$189/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
3 BR on shared beachfront property with beachfront access/patio seating!

3 BR on shared beachfront property with beachfront access/patio seating!

3 beds 1 bath
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$243/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
3 BR on shared beachfront property with beachfront access/patio seating!

3 BR on shared beachfront property with beachfront access/patio seating!

3 beds 1 bath
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$241/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
6 Person Hot Tub!! 3 Doors Down From The Beach- Garage Game Room- Pets Welcome!

6 Person Hot Tub!! 3 Doors Down From The Beach- Garage Game Room- Pets Welcome!

3 beds 1 bath
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$370/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
Beachfront Condo in the heart of Sylvan Beach

Beachfront Condo in the heart of Sylvan Beach

2 beds 2 baths
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$376/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
Sylvans Hidden Gem "The Lilly Pad" w/ Murphy Bed! Internal name: Lilly - Studio sleeps 4

Sylvans Hidden Gem "The Lilly Pad" w/ Murphy Bed! Internal name: Lilly - Studio sleeps 4

1 bed 1 bath
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$132/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
The Cove at Sylvan Beach - Pet friendly lakeside cottage with a pontoon boat!

The Cove at Sylvan Beach - Pet friendly lakeside cottage with a pontoon boat!

2 beds 2 baths
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$357/night
View Details → Book on VRBO

More destinations in New York

New York (1291) Lake Placid (346) Montauk (303) Lake George (252) Saratoga Springs (245) Hampton Bays (244) Brooklyn (241) Queens (229) East Hampton (202) Buffalo (190) Southampton (169) Amagansett (166) Niagara Falls (149) Downtown (148) Sag Harbor (144) Penn Yan (121) Midtown (118) Canandaigua (105) Ithaca (103) Woodstock (98)