Fly Creek, New York

Vacation Rentals in Fly Creek, New York

Discover 13 vacation rental properties in Fly Creek. From 2 to 12 bedrooms. Average $505/night. 100% have pools.

13 verified listings Book securely on VRBO Prices updated March 2026

13 properties available

3 min. to DreamsPark & 21 min. to CASV, 33 ft. Long Heated Pool, Fun, & Private

3 min. to DreamsPark & 21 min. to CASV, 33 ft. Long Heated Pool, Fun, & Private

12 beds 8 baths
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$2,023/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
1825 Farmhouse - One of Three Rentals in Fly Creek, 5 minutes from Cooperstown

1825 Farmhouse - One of Three Rentals in Fly Creek, 5 minutes from Cooperstown

4 beds 3 baths
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$226/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
Cooperstown Mountain View Manor 5 minutes to Dream Park 2 minutes Hall of Fame

Cooperstown Mountain View Manor 5 minutes to Dream Park 2 minutes Hall of Fame

4 beds 2 baths
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$428/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
Spacious, private and peaceful 1st floor Apartment on Fly Creek

Spacious, private and peaceful 1st floor Apartment on Fly Creek

2 beds 1 bath
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$272/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
1825 Cottage - One of Three rentals in Fly Creek 5 minutes to Cooperstown

1825 Cottage - One of Three rentals in Fly Creek 5 minutes to Cooperstown

4 beds 2 baths
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$268/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
Charming Historic Home < 4 Mi to Cooperstown!

Charming Historic Home < 4 Mi to Cooperstown!

3 beds 2 baths
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$268/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
1825 Barn - 1 of 3 Rentals in Fly Creek, 5 minutes to Cooperstown

1825 Barn - 1 of 3 Rentals in Fly Creek, 5 minutes to Cooperstown

3 beds 3 baths
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$201/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
ENJOY! Relax and Unwind in Tranquil Fly Creek - 5 min to Downtown Cooperstown

ENJOY! Relax and Unwind in Tranquil Fly Creek - 5 min to Downtown Cooperstown

4 beds 2 baths
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$721/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
*Oaks Creek Cottage*ON the Creek*3bd 2bath Sleeps6

*Oaks Creek Cottage*ON the Creek*3bd 2bath Sleeps6

3 beds 2 baths
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$356/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
*Bissell House* 5MilestoHOF

*Bissell House* 5MilestoHOF

3 beds 2 baths
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$323/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
"Resort-Like-Property" -- 10min. to CDP -- Heated Pool -- 6min. to Coop-Village

"Resort-Like-Property" -- 10min. to CDP -- Heated Pool -- 6min. to Coop-Village

8 beds 6 baths
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$900/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
*Fly Creek Manor*3.7Mi to HOF*4Bedrooms2Ba/Sleep10

*Fly Creek Manor*3.7Mi to HOF*4Bedrooms2Ba/Sleep10

4 beds 2 baths
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$384/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
Beautiful Fly Creek Carriage House close to Coop!

Beautiful Fly Creek Carriage House close to Coop!

2 beds 1 bath
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$192/night
View Details → Book on VRBO

More destinations in New York

New York (1291) Lake Placid (346) Montauk (303) Lake George (252) Saratoga Springs (245) Hampton Bays (244) Brooklyn (241) Queens (229) East Hampton (202) Buffalo (190) Southampton (169) Amagansett (166) Niagara Falls (149) Downtown (148) Sag Harbor (144) Penn Yan (121) Midtown (118) Canandaigua (105) Ithaca (103) Woodstock (98)