Cayuga, New York

Vacation Rentals in Cayuga, New York

Discover 21 vacation rental properties in Cayuga. From 1 to 8 bedrooms. Average $460/night. 100% have pools.

21 verified listings Book securely on VRBO Prices updated March 2026

21 properties available

Sunset Bay:"A Quaint Bungalow by the Lake"

Sunset Bay:"A Quaint Bungalow by the Lake"

3 beds 1 bath
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$194/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
Tom’s Lake Views- Charming 2bedroom Apt nestled in the heart of the Finger lakes

Tom’s Lake Views- Charming 2bedroom Apt nestled in the heart of the Finger lakes

2 beds 1 bath
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$152/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
Newly remodeled Cayuga Cottage with private dock on the sunset bay.

Newly remodeled Cayuga Cottage with private dock on the sunset bay.

3 beds 2 baths
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$251/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
Cozy & cheerful 3 bedroom cottage on Cayuga Lake

Cozy & cheerful 3 bedroom cottage on Cayuga Lake

3 beds 1 bath
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$201/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
2 decks with hot tub & grill 200' of waterfront.

2 decks with hot tub & grill 200' of waterfront.

6 beds 3 baths
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$804/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
Newly Remodeled Home - Whataview of Cayuga Lake

Newly Remodeled Home - Whataview of Cayuga Lake

4 beds 2 baths
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$552/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
La Bella Vita: "Spectacular Cayuga Lake Sunsets!"

La Bella Vita: "Spectacular Cayuga Lake Sunsets!"

5 beds 3 baths
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$493/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
Spacious Lakehouse on Cayuga Lake with bonus efficiency apartment, great rates!

Spacious Lakehouse on Cayuga Lake with bonus efficiency apartment, great rates!

5 beds 3 baths
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$277/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
Cayuga Dacha...Lakefront retreat in the beautiful Finger Lakes

Cayuga Dacha...Lakefront retreat in the beautiful Finger Lakes

2 beds 1 bath
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$255/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
Lakeview Cottage: "Beautiful Sunset Views!"

Lakeview Cottage: "Beautiful Sunset Views!"

2 beds 1 bath
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$241/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
Lakeside Beautiful 1 Story Cottage With Panoramic View Of Peaceful Cayuga Lake<br><br>

Lakeside Beautiful 1 Story Cottage With Panoramic View Of Peaceful Cayuga Lake<br><br>

3 beds 1 bath
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$401/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
Camp Onondaga Fully Restored Historic Lake Cottage

Camp Onondaga Fully Restored Historic Lake Cottage

1 bed 1 bath
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$154/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
Sweet Retreat: "Family Cottage with Great Views!"

Sweet Retreat: "Family Cottage with Great Views!"

3 beds 1 bath
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$199/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
Lakefront Cayuga Retreat w/ Private Deck & Hot Tub

Lakefront Cayuga Retreat w/ Private Deck & Hot Tub

4 beds 3 baths
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$489/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
Large Newly Remodeled Lake house right on the water. Sleeps 24+

Large Newly Remodeled Lake house right on the water. Sleeps 24+

8 beds 5 baths
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$2,261/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
Remodeled Peaceful Retreat

Remodeled Peaceful Retreat

5 beds 2 baths
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$646/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
Lake-view retreat with dock access, firepits, & large yard

Lake-view retreat with dock access, firepits, & large yard

6 beds 2 baths
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$404/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
The Boat House - Cayuga Lake Oasis! Beautiful sunsets from the Hot Tub!

The Boat House - Cayuga Lake Oasis! Beautiful sunsets from the Hot Tub!

3 beds 2 baths
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$699/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
Renovated Lake Cottage: Wineries, Wildlife and Relaxation - Eagles Nest

Renovated Lake Cottage: Wineries, Wildlife and Relaxation - Eagles Nest

3 beds 1 bath
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$305/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
Holiday Cove: "A Great Place for a Family Vacation"

Holiday Cove: "A Great Place for a Family Vacation"

4 beds 2 baths
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$251/night
View Details → Book on VRBO
Bring The Family To Our Corner Of The Finger Lakes

Bring The Family To Our Corner Of The Finger Lakes

4 beds 2 baths
PoolA/CWiFiBalcony
$427/night
View Details → Book on VRBO

More destinations in New York

New York (1291) Lake Placid (346) Montauk (303) Lake George (252) Saratoga Springs (245) Hampton Bays (244) Brooklyn (241) Queens (229) East Hampton (202) Buffalo (190) Southampton (169) Amagansett (166) Niagara Falls (149) Downtown (148) Sag Harbor (144) Penn Yan (121) Midtown (118) Canandaigua (105) Ithaca (103) Woodstock (98)